The Top Ten Project: An Introduction
Long ago, before the words "social" and "media" were forever conjoined, there was an online discussion board. Located deep in the bowels of the Internet, it was a place where film enthusiasts could engage in spirited debate about cinema of all stripes. There was a place for announcements about film-related events, a wide array of in-jokes and other Vernacular, and an ongoing project in which group members would submit their lists of the best films from whatever years they saw fit to submit. These lists were then collected and tabulated by a handful of people, who posted the results as a means of gauging group tastes and allowing everyone to update their personal to-see lists.
And then… it stopped.
Much of the group's activities continued elsewhere, in venues like Film Twitter and Letterboxd. But the old "History Project" did not make the same transition, little more than a memory of some of the group members, who maintained their own lists but didn't have anywhere to submit these lists to be part of a larger consensus.
Until now, that is.
With The Top Ten Project, we have enlisted many of the contributors to the original poll, with respect to the contributors who we have lost over the years, like the late greats Jim Ridley and Andrew Johnston. We have also invited a number of new voices to join our ranks as well. For reference, here is a list of all our contributors, with links to their web sites or Letterboxd pages where available:
Steven Carlson
Pol Clark
Mike D'Angelo
Erik Gregersen
Jeremy Heilman
Scott Kelly
Don Marks
Jeff McMahon
Victor J. Morton
Charles Odell
Jason Overbeck
Theo Panayides
Zach Ralston
Peter Reiher
Dan Sallitt
Michael Sicinski
Chris Stults
Ryan Swen
Scout Tafoya
Adam Villani
Jeff Vorndam
George Wu
Ryan Wu
Nicholas Zeifman
And yes, we recognize that this is a highly male-centric group of voters. We are on the lookout for passionate list-making types who can participate in the next incarnation of the project, regardless of gender. If you would be interested in taking part, contact us at themurielawards@gmail.com.
Now, the ground rules:
- Participants submitted their top ten lists for any year from the dawn of cinema through 2020. Only lists that had at least ten titles were considered, and if more than ten titles were submitted for a given year, only the first ten were counted.
- Eligibility was based on IMDb date as of the voting deadline. Movies of any length were eligible, as were self-contained TV miniseries. Individual television episodes were not eligible, but some single seasons were considered, if they were all Broadcast during the same calendar year and contained a single over-arching narrative. See the 2017 list for the obvious example.
- Points for the submitted lists were given starting with 14 points for the #1 film, 13 points for #2, down to 5 points for #10. For unranked lists, all films would receive 9.5 points apiece.
Below are the results for every year for which we received at least one good list. Along with our top 25 finishers, we have also listed the results for other major films of each year, including Oscar Best Picture nominees, festival award winners, and films in the They Shoot Pictures Don't They Top 1000 list.
Again, I would like to thank everyone who participated in this poll. I hope we can continue this in the future.
Enjoy!
Sincerely,
Pol Clark
Administrator
And then… it stopped.
Much of the group's activities continued elsewhere, in venues like Film Twitter and Letterboxd. But the old "History Project" did not make the same transition, little more than a memory of some of the group members, who maintained their own lists but didn't have anywhere to submit these lists to be part of a larger consensus.
Until now, that is.
With The Top Ten Project, we have enlisted many of the contributors to the original poll, with respect to the contributors who we have lost over the years, like the late greats Jim Ridley and Andrew Johnston. We have also invited a number of new voices to join our ranks as well. For reference, here is a list of all our contributors, with links to their web sites or Letterboxd pages where available:
Steven Carlson
Pol Clark
Mike D'Angelo
Erik Gregersen
Jeremy Heilman
Scott Kelly
Don Marks
Jeff McMahon
Victor J. Morton
Charles Odell
Jason Overbeck
Theo Panayides
Zach Ralston
Peter Reiher
Dan Sallitt
Michael Sicinski
Chris Stults
Ryan Swen
Scout Tafoya
Adam Villani
Jeff Vorndam
George Wu
Ryan Wu
Nicholas Zeifman
And yes, we recognize that this is a highly male-centric group of voters. We are on the lookout for passionate list-making types who can participate in the next incarnation of the project, regardless of gender. If you would be interested in taking part, contact us at themurielawards@gmail.com.
Now, the ground rules:
- Participants submitted their top ten lists for any year from the dawn of cinema through 2020. Only lists that had at least ten titles were considered, and if more than ten titles were submitted for a given year, only the first ten were counted.
- Eligibility was based on IMDb date as of the voting deadline. Movies of any length were eligible, as were self-contained TV miniseries. Individual television episodes were not eligible, but some single seasons were considered, if they were all Broadcast during the same calendar year and contained a single over-arching narrative. See the 2017 list for the obvious example.
- Points for the submitted lists were given starting with 14 points for the #1 film, 13 points for #2, down to 5 points for #10. For unranked lists, all films would receive 9.5 points apiece.
Below are the results for every year for which we received at least one good list. Along with our top 25 finishers, we have also listed the results for other major films of each year, including Oscar Best Picture nominees, festival award winners, and films in the They Shoot Pictures Don't They Top 1000 list.
Again, I would like to thank everyone who participated in this poll. I hope we can continue this in the future.
Enjoy!
Sincerely,
Pol Clark
Administrator
Thank you very much for your hard work on this project. It's great to see this thing revived, and frankly has given me an impetus to fill in my gaps in the canon.
ReplyDelete