2018 [22 lists]

 


1. Burning / Beoning (Lee Chang-dong, South Korea) [87 points / 8 votes] {pictured ahove}
2. Leave No Trace (Debra Granik, USA) [85/9]
3. Transit (Christian Petzold, Germany) [84/8]
4. BlacKkKlansman (Spike Lee, USA) [69/6]
5. The Favourite (Yorgos Lanthimos, UK) [68/6]
6. The Ballad of Buster Scruggs (Joel and Ethan Coen) [65/7]
7. Support the Girls (Andrew Bujalski, USA) [58/5]
8. Shoplifters (Hirokazu Kore-eda, Japan) [56/5]
9. If Beale Street Could Talk (Barry Jenkins, USA) [49/5]
10. Sunset (Nemes László, Hungary) [48/5]
11. The Other Side of the Wind (Orson Welles, USA) [48/4]
12. Free Solo (Jimmy Chin and Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi, USA) [45/6]
13. Her Smell (Alex Ross Perry, USA) [42/4]
14. Private Life (Tamara Jenkins, USA) [38/4]
15. Bisbee '17 (Robert Greene, USA) [36/3]
16. The House That Jack Built (Lars von Trier, Denmark) [34/4]
17. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (Bob Perischetti, Peter Ramsey, and Rodney Rothman, USA) [33/4]
18. Roma (Alfonso Cuarón, Mexico) [32/3]
19. Sorry to Bother You (Boots Riley, USA) [31/4]
20 (tie). Cold War (Pawel Pawlikowski, Poland) [31/3]
20 (tie). Isle of Dogs (Wes Anderson, USA) [31/3]
22. The Grand Bizarre (Jodie Mack, USA) [30/3]
23. An Elephant Sitting Still (Hu Bo, China P.R.) [28/3]
24 (tie). Ash Is Purest White (Jia Zhangke, China P.R.) [26/3]
24 (tie). Madeline's Madeline (Josephine Decker, USA) [26/3]

Other notable films: Black Panther (Coogler) [24/2]; A Star Is Born (B. Cooper) [17/2]; Bohemian Rhapsody (Singer) [no votes]; Green Book (P. Farrelly) [no votes]; Touch Me Not (A. Pintilie) [no votes]; Vice (McKay) [no votes]

Contributors: Carlson, Clark, D'Angelo, Gregersen, Heilman, Kelly, McMahon, Morton, Odell, Overbeck, Panayides, Ralston, Reiher, Sallitt, Sicinski, Stults, Swen, Tafoya, Vorndam, G.Wu, R.Wu, Zeifman

Comments

  1. Not a single MCU film appears on any top 10 despite it being one of the most popular franchises in the entire history of movies. Critics shouldn’t consider populist appeal in picking out worthwhile films, but reading reviews of these films over the years, I see a blatant bias against and an evident contempt for the genre as a whole amidst a superhero backlash whereas the merits of the individual films are overlooked in my eyes. Nolan’s THE DARK KNIGHT gets to be the “but I have black friends” exception even though that movie makes absolutely no sense and its action sequences pale in comparison to many Marvel films. I feel critics often get caught up so much in respectability that they lose sight of the importance of fun. THOR: RAGNAROK is one of the funniest comedies in years. AVENGERS: INFINITY WAR employs spectacle on an immense scale while doing a miraculous job of respecting over a dozen characters, all of whom get their emotional beats. It is also pretty funny. Audiences have embraced these films for good reason.

    However, good on the group for apparently recognizing that BLACK PANTHER is not some vastly superior product to most MCU films by not placing it in the top 25. It’s actually pretty much of a piece with the other films and in the middle of the pack of them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't know if it's strictly a matter of critical bias in the case of the MCU's lack of representation on our lists. After all, if you look at the format of this particular poll, it's not a simple gauge of critical consensus (a la Rotten Tomatoes) but rather of passion. The voters in this poll have, in many cases, seen hundreds of new movies for each year in the past decade or so. And in winnowing their lists down to ten favorites, they are bound to cut some movies they like quite a bit. It's just how it goes.

      I would have to look at the overall results to know for sure, but I would imagine that there are at least a few critics besides yourself who have seen fit to recognize the MCU over the years. I also know that there are some other relatively recent franchises that have regularly garnered votes from fans among our ranks. Setting aside obvious cases like MAD MAX and TOY STORY, I'm pretty sure movies from the JOHN WICK and JACKASS franchises have received love, and I've cast votes for more than one MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE movie.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Top Ten Project: An Introduction

2015 [20 lists]